A poet, his father and Black baseball

“The Negro league’s like a light somewhere. Back over your shoulder. As you go away. A warmth still, connected to laughter and self-love. The collective black aura that can only be duplicated with black conversation or music.”

— Imamu Amiri Baraka, in his autobiography

Imamu Amiri Baraka

Here’s another quick placeholder post based on random databases that caught my eye while I work on longer projects. This one is about Imamu Amiri Baraka, an influential and often controversial poet, author, thinker and cultural commentator, often dubbed the poet laureate of the Black Arts Movement and a key figure in the overall Black Power Movement.

The database in question is Baraka’s career and personal papers. I first learned about Baraka more than 20 years ago during my time in grad school at Indiana University when I was working on what I had hoped would be a dual master’s in journalism and African-American Studies. (That never came to be, sadly. The School of Journalism was recalcitrant the entire way and in effect blocked me from finishing the AAS half of my degree. And actually, if there’s anyone who knows a relatively simple, low-cost way of finishing my AAS master’s, please let me know!) My professors Fred McElroy (RIP), John McCluskey and Portia Maultsby were keys to my education about Baraka.

The papers in the online archive include interviews with Baraka and other people close to him and involved in the Black Arts Movement and Black Power Movement. One such Q&A was conducted in January 1986 by Komozi Woodard, a prolific author who’s currently a history professor at Sarah Lawrence College.

At one point in the interview, Baraka discusses his childhood watching Newark Eagles games and seeing the players in person.

(Editor’s note: I’m quoting these interviews more or less verbatim from the digital versions that exist in the Baraka papers. The text is probably from a direct transcription, so the grammar isn’t great and many of the names and places aren’t included or are spelled incorrectly.)

Here’s one excerpt:

BARAKA: … [W]hen there was black baseball before integration killed black baseball and our players began to play with those other folks, Newark was the world champions, the last year of the black baseball league Newark Eagles were the world champions.* Down at [left blank, but presumably Ruppert] Stadium, the bloods took the seats, these cushions they were sitting on and threw them all out in the field. But it was a hotel called the Grand Hotel on Market Street, a black owned hotel on West Market Street; right there now where they are going to build the vocational school, right across from there right in the Grand Hotel where all the baseball players and the fast light people used to hang out. My father used to take me there because we used to go see black baseball every Sunday. Whenever the Eagles were in town we would go down there. And afterwards they would go up there and have a little drink and he would walk me around. This is Monty Irving [sic] this is Larry Doby, Pat Patterson and I got to meet all those …” **

(*The Eagles actually won the title in 1946, two seasons before the second Negro National League’s demise in ’48.)

(**Baraka expanded on these thoughts in his autobiography. For more info on that, see the end of this post.)

Ruppert Stadium

The database’s files also feature an interview conducted by Woodard of Honey Ward, a friend of Baraka’s and an influential Black rights and urban-renewal advocate in his own right. Ward was born in Key West, Fla., but he and his family moved to Newark when he was 2. Here’s an excerpt of that interview:

KOMOZI: Were there a lot of black sports institutions in Newark at that time?

HONEY: Well you had your oldtimers, you had baseball like the Homestead Grays and the Newark Eagles and you had the Kansas City Monarchs that Satcho [sic] Paige came out. Marvin Irwin [sic] played with the Newark Eagles. Larry Doby came out of a black team. Jackie Robinson even played in the black league. The New York Black Yankees and down in [Ruppert] Stadium which is torn down which was owned by the Newark Bears [a longtime white minor-league team] … . My father would take us down on Sundays to see, Ray Dandridge’s father [?] they were baseball players. I remember seeing Satcho Paige playing down there on Sundays, it was all black.

KOMOZI: Were there a lot of people down there?

HONEY: Yeah, the blacks would go down there and watch black baseball because at that time baseball was jim crowed too. Blacks were [not] allowed to play in the majors, the white majors.

Baraka’s papers included references to other authors’ works that themselves mention Black baseball. In notes on Robert C. Weaver’s 1948 book, “The Negro Ghetto,” Baraka lays out this direct quote from Weaver’s book:

“Newark’s deterioration dates from the 1930s, at a time when there was often-repeated praise for the fine department stores, the great insurance companies, the excellent schools, the cleanliness of Broad Street, the influence of its newspapers, and even the vaunted abilities of the Newark Bears, the finest minor league team that baseball had ever seen. [The] [I]nept, politic-ridden [sic] government did little to stem the tide of decline after World War II.”

The database documents also include brief references to baseball in general as a potential source of political activism and focus of efforts toward racial and social justice. Particularly, Baraka’s commitment to communism and Marxism appears to have led him to write his own work as well as examine and cite the texts of other communists in America. And, quite naturally, baseball inevitably, if briefly or tangentially, intersects with such topics. (For example, one of the most passionate and forceful advocates of integration in major league baseball was Lester Rodney, the sports editor of the communist newspaper The Daily Worker, who played a key but somewhat unsung role in the successful entrance of African Americans into Organized Baseball.)

Thus, it’s not surprising that Baraka’s papers, for example, feature a copy of a 1933 essay, “The Struggle for the Leninist Position on the Negro Question in the U.S.A.,” by Harry Haywood, a lifelong, staunch Stalinist/Maoist thinker, writer and activist.

In the essay, Haywood outlines, point by point, the communist platform as a means toward racial and social equality and justice, and one of the points involves sports and athletics, including baseball. In the essay, Haywood wrote that communists demand:

“The right of Negro athletes to participate in all athletic games with white athletes, including rowing, swimming, inter-collegiate basketball, football, major league baseball, etc.; against Jim-Crow policies of the AAU in swimming pools, etc.”

Harry Haywood

Also found in the Baraka archives are issues of “Main Trend,” a publication of Baraka’s Student Organization for Black Unity (SOBU) and Youth Organization for Black Unity (YOBU) from 1978-81. One of the editions features an article titled, “Baseball Belongs to the People,” which goes through the history of the national pastime – from its professionalization and early attempts at players’ unions in the 19th century, through the reserve clause, commercialization of the sport, segregation and desegregation, and the advent of free agency.

Overall, the article heavily criticizes the team owners and other powers-that-be – the piece dubs them “the capitalists” – in the sport for exploiting both the players and the fans to maximize profit and enrich the owners’ own coffers.

“The history of professional baseball cannot be separated from the history of capitalist exploitation in the U.S.,” the article stated.

However, the article also stresses that for as long as capitalists have allegedly tried their damnedest to treat baseball as their own personal piggy bank, “the people” – the players and fans – have been resisting and fighting for their rights and their share of the proverbial baseball pie. It concludes:

“So long as there is exploitation in baseball there is resistance to exploitation. And it is up to us to support this resistance. Us – be people who invented baseball and who fill the rosters of every team in the major leagues. Us – the most exploited and most revolutionary class in capitalist society.

Baseball belongs to the people!” [italics in original].

As part of its analysis and repudiation of extreme, unjust capitalism in the national pastime, the article notes that during the late 19th century and into the 20th, as the owners were tightening their grip on the game, “[I]t was during this period that racism ‘triumphed’ [quotes in original] in professional baseball, as the owners refused to hire black players, condemning them to the Negro Leagues until Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier in 1947.”

The piece also refers to the court fight of Curt Flood, a Black player who unsuccessfully challenged the major leagues’ stifling reserve clause. It also asserts that “racism is still rampant, despite all the black and Spanish players,” citing lingering pay inequality and the hostility Reggie Jackson received at the time for supposedly getting notorious Yankees manager Billy Martin fired.

**Now, back to Baraka discussing the influence the Negro Leagues had on him and on the African-American community as a whole in, “The Autobiography of LeRoi Jones/Amiri Baraka,” originally published in 1984. (LeRoi Jones was his original name.)

In the book, Baraka further recalls his experiences with his father at Newark Eagles games, and explains why the team, and Black baseball in general, had so much impact on him and the Black public.

“Very little in my life was as heightened (in anticipation and reward) for me as that,” he stated. “What was that? Some black men playing baseball? No, but beyond that, so deep in fact it carried and carries memories and even a politics with it that still makes me shudder.

“But coming down through that would heighten my sense because I could dig I would soon be standing in that line to get in, with my old man. But lines of all black people! Dressed up like they would for going to the game, in those bright lost summers. Full of noise and identification slapped greetings over and around folks. ’Cause after all in that town of 300,000 that 20 to 30 percent of the population (then) had a high recognition rate for each other. They worked together, lived in the same neighborhoods, went to church (if they did) together, and all the rest of it, even played together.

“The Newark Eagles would have your heart there on the field, from what they was doing. From how they looked. But these were professional ball players. Legitimate black heroes. And we were intimate with them in a way and they were extensions of all of us, there, in a way that the Yankees and Dodgers and what not could never be!

“We knew that they were us – raised up to another, higher degree. Shit, and the Eagles, people knew, talked to before and after the game. …

Leon Day

“That was the year they had Doby and Irvin and [Lennie] Pearson and [Bob] Harvey and Pat Patterson, a schoolteacher, on third base, and Leon Day was the star pitcher, and he showed out opening day! But coming into that stadium those Sunday afternoons carried a sweetness with it. The hot dogs and root beers! (They have never tasted that good again.) A little big-eyed boy holding his father’s hand.

“There was a sense of completion in all that. The black men (and the women) sitting there all participated in those games at a much higher level than anything else I knew. In the sense that they were not excluded from either identification with or knowledge of what the Eagles did and were. It was like we all communicated with each other and possessed ourselves at a more human level than was usually possible out in cold whitey land.

“Coming in that stadium with dudes and ladies calling out, ‘Hey, Roy, boy he look just like you.’ Or: ‘You look just like your father.’ Besides that note and attention, the Eagles there were something we possessed. It was not us as George Washington Carver or Marian Anderson, some figment of white people’s lack of imagination, it was us as we wanted to be and how we wanted to be seen being looked at by ourselves in some kind of loud communion.”

Baraka further describes the Eagles, the Negro Leagues and the Black community a fair amount, but I’ll close with his thoughts about Jackie Robinson and integration overall. He was conflicted, to say the least:

“But you know, they can slip in on you another way, Bro. Sell you some hand magic, or not sell you, but sell somebody somewhere some. And you be standin’ there and all of a sudden you hear about – what? – Jeckie Rawbeanson. I could tell right away, really, that the dude in the hood had been at work. No, really, it was like I heard the wheels and metal wires in his voice, the imperfected humanoid, his first words ‘Moy nayhme is Jeckie Rawbeanson.’ Some Ray Bradbury shit they had mashed on us. I knew it. A skin-covered humanoid to bust up our shit.

“I don’t want to get political and talk bad about ‘integration.’ Like what a straight-out trick it was. To rip off what you had in the name of what you ain’t never gonna get. So the destruction of the Negro National League. The destruction of the Eagles, Greys [sic], Black Yankees, Elite Giants, Cuban Stars, Clowns, Monarchs, Black Barons, to what must we attribute that? We’re going to the big leagues. Is that what the cry was on those Afric’ shores when the European capitalists and African feudal lords got together and palmed our future. ‘WE’RE GOING TO THE BIG LEAGUES!’

“So out of the California laboratories of USC, a synthetic colored guy was imperfected and soon we would be trooping back into the holy see of racist approbation. [Robinson actually attended UCLA, not USC.] So that we could sit next to drunken racists by and by. And watch our heroes put down by slimy cocksuckers who are so stupid they would uphold Henry and his Ford and be put in chains by both while helping to tighten ours.

“Can you dig that red-faced backwardness that would question whether Satchel Paige could pitch in the same league with … who?

“For many, the Dodgers could take out some of the sting and for those who thought it really meant we was getting in America. (But that cooled out. A definition of pathology in blackface would be exactly that, someone, some Nigra, who thunk they was in this! Owow!) But the scarecrow J. R. for all his ersatz ‘blackness’ could represent the shadow world of the Negro integrating into America. A farce. But many of us fell for that and felt for him, really. Even though a lot of us knew the wholly artificial disconnected thing that Jackie Robinson was. Still when the backward Crackers would drop black cats on the field or idiots like Dixie Walker (who wouldn’t even a made the team if Josh Gibson or Buck Leonard was on the scene) would mumble some of his unpatented Ku Klux dumbness, we got uptight, for us, not just for J. R.”

What do you think of Baraka’s controversial take on Jackie Robinson and integration?

The FBI’s paranoid history even includes a national hero

Jackie

I looked through the list of the databases available to me for a quick post while I continue to work on some bigger projects, and the one featuring the FBI’s declassified files and documents from the agency’s decades-long surveillance of the Civil Rights Movement caught my eye.

It’s pretty well known that the longtime and infamous FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover – everybody’s pal, my friend and yours – and his agents kinda had it in for everyone from Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. to Malcolm X to Ralph Abernathy to Huey Newton.

One of the central foci of the chillingly omniscient was the supposed “communist infiltration” of the Civil Rights Movement, including Dr. King’s Southern Christian Leadership Conference, or SCLC, as well as the reactionary, bigoted pushback – like the countless bombings and bomb threats – from white segregationists.

So, on a lark, I decided to search through these declassified files to see which famous sporting figures might happen to pop up. I especially looked for Jackie Robinson in them, given his participation in and support of the Civil Rights Movement.

And, wouldn’t you know it, his name does, in fact, pop up a few times in the FBI’s surveillance files.

Now, he doesn’t appear too often, indicating that he seemingly wasn’t a primary focus of the surveillance, but he is in there, unfortunately.

Many of these instances center around his appearances at official SCLC meetings or conventions, including the organization’s 1962 annual national meeting, held that year in Birmingham, Ala., from Sept. 25-28.

In the days leading up to the convention, one confidential FBI communication indicated that Robinson was scheduled to be one of the speakers, along with leading Civil Rights lights Fred Shuttlesworth and Adam Clayton Powell. The surveillance team also stated that their were no demonstrations scheduled by the organizers of the meeting.

Communications after the conclusion of the convention reported that no violence of major incidents occurred during the gathering, and that everything proceeded peacefully. In one memo, an agent described Robinson’s appearance as a speaker: “Jackie Robinson spoke at SCLC banquet night of [Sept. 25] and indicated he wanted President Kennedy to take action in Civil Rights.”

J. Edgar Hoover

However, an ensuing document reporting on the gathering including much of Jackie’s speech verbatim – it covers roughly two full pages of single-line text, seemingly indicating that the agents focused extra attention on the former baseball great.

In his speech, Robinson urged attendees to support and donate to the effort to rebuild several Black churches that had recently been burned down by segregationists.

“It has been tough for me not to hit back [on news of the burnings],” Jackie said. “Anyone who would burn a church is the lowest type of individual in the world. They must be stopped for America’s sake. …

“My mother told me a long time ago not to go South,” he added. “I kept her advice for a long time. I don’t believe I could turn the other cheek down here. At least that was the way I felt when I saw those burned churches in Sasser, Georgia. … This is all of our fight.”

Those last comments are particularly interesting given that, when he debuted with the Brooklyn Dodgers and throughout his on-field career, he did, in fact, figuratively turn the other cheek while enduring horrific abuse from fans and other players, because he knew that he simply had to do so if he was to succeed, both as a player and a sociocultural trailblazer and bellwether.

Jackie then urged President Kennedy to actively join the fight for justice: “I am not interested in the President’s talk, what we need is action.”

He added that “[T]hey should not worry so much about sending the Peace Corps to Africa, they should send it to Birmingham, Alabama and Mississippi. There are many backward people here. I don’t believe we will continue to permit these people to deny us our privileges and opportunities.”

He expressed his support for the Freedom Riders and obliquely criticized Bull Conner. Robinson concluded his speech:

“Even though I have lost many awards because of my stand, I have not lost my self respect. They tell me that Birmingham is the worst city in the United States. I was born in Georgia but I got away quick. I have seen the love and admiration people have for Dr. King in New York. They have asked him many questions, but have not been able to twist him up. I am sorry we can’t participate more.”

The declassified archive of FBI surveillance documents also included brief references to Jackie in its reportage on the 1964 SCLC Convention, held from Sept. 26-Oct. 2 of that year in Savannah, Ga. The interdepartmental memorandums stressed that organizers of the SCLC gathering had received bomb threats warning of attacks on the convention. However, the agents later reported that the meeting proceeded without incident.

The references to Robinson in the documents were brief and included a notation that a story that had just appeared in the Savannah Morning News; the memo reported that the article had stated that Robinson had criticized Adam Clayton Powell for not being active enough in the Civil Rights fight, to the detriment of the Movement.

Barry Goldwater

The surveillance reportage also stated that news coverage of Jackie’s speech at the 1964 convention had sharply condemned Republican presidential candidate Barry Goldwater and that he had “implored the nation’s Negroes to defeat” the GOP candidate. Such statements are key, given the fact that Jackie had previously supported Republican positions and candidates, including Richard Nixon in the 1960 presidential election.

Many of the other references to Robinson in the FBI files centered somewhat around his conflicts with and criticisms by leaders of the Nation of Islam, the Black Muslim organization popularized most prominently by Malcolm X.

Jackie and the Nation did not, shall we say, get along. The former, as reflected in the FBI communications and memorandums, believed the latter was hateful against whites, and Robinson was staunchly opposed to the Nation’s militant advocacy of Black separatism and use of violence in the face of white violence.

For their part, Malcolm X and/or the Nation’s leader, Elijah Muhammad, frequently leveled criticisms toward Robinson, and the FBI’s agents were sure to note it. For example, the federal surveillance documents reported that, on March 9, 1964 – one day after he broke from the Nation of Islam – Malcolm appeared on a news show in New York City and was interviewed extensively by commentator Joe Durso, who at one point in the interview asked Malcolm what the Malcolm thought about Jackie Robinson calling the Muslim leader “a threat to integration.” Malcolm responded by referring to Robinson’s association with then-New York Governor Nelson Rockefeller, a Republican who later became vice president under Gerald Ford.

“Jackie Robinson has just become a part of Governor Rockefeller’s political machine,” Malcolm said, as quoted in the FBI report, “and it is his job to make Negroes think that Nelson Rockefeller is the Saviour [sic] who will lead us to the promised land of integration.”

And, reported FBI agents to their superiors, Elijah Muhammad stated on an October 1965 news program in Chicago that “such prominent [B]lack men Dr. Ralph Bunche, Jackie Robinson and the like only serve the white man and do nothing to better their [B]lack brothers.”

One of the battlegrounds, as it were, of this verbal conflict between Jackie and the Nation was the new media powerhouse that was television. Robinson occasionally appeared on TV news programs that featured a panel of guests discussing the Nation of Islam, Muhammad and Malcolm X, and when Jackie did make those appearances, he was included in the FBI’s surveillance reports. 

The declassified archives, for example, include an interdepartmental FBI memorandum describing the now-infamous five-part documentary series on WNTA-TV by broadcast news greats Mike Wallace and Louis Lomax that was broadcast for a week in July 19. The FBI report noted that Jackie Robinson took part in the discussion panel.

Called “The Hate That Hate Produced,” the series examined the burgeoning Black nationalist movements, with much of the focus on the Nation of Islam. (I haven’t seen the series, but from what I gather, it was biased, one-sided and purposefully sensationalistic and inflammatory.)

Malcolm X

Finally, the FBI files include a few articles/commentaries written by Robinson and published in various newspapers that were part of the back-and-forth between Jackie and Malcolm in the press. Malcolm X at the time was a lightning rod for controversy, and because of his radicalism, the FBI focused a massive amount of its surveillance on him.

Robinson’s published missives frequently came after Malcolm X had in the media recently vociferously criticized Jackie and other mainstream Civil Rights figures, including, for example, an interview Malcolm gave to reporters in May 1963, and the FBI was quick to note it in one of the agency’s voluminous reports on Malcolm’s words and activities.

In his comments to the journalists, Malcolm asserted that the majority of African Americans who took part in a recent protest in Birmingham rejected Dr. King’s message of non-violence, and the FBI memo noting the statements by reporting that “in the interview … subject had attacked Martin Luther King, Jackie Robinson and [boxing champion] Floyd Patterson as unwitting tools of white liberals.”

One ensuing piece by Robinson, published in the Dec. 14, 1963, issue of the Amsterdam News came in the form of an open letter to Malcolm in which Robinson defends his own record on Civil Rights and the social justice effort, and vociferously criticizes Malcolm’s militancy.

Other published commentaries by Robinson, however, quite significantly came after Malcolm’s March 1964 break with the Nation of Islam, his rejection of Black separatism and the softening of his criticism toward whites. One such column by Jackie, coming in early May 1964, continued to harshly criticize Malcolm, and it blamed prolific media coverage of Malcolm’s earlier, more militant activity and statements, as well as a lack of pushback from society as a whole, for the elevation of Malcolm to hero status.

Then, a July 1964 article published a couple more months later expressed Robinson’s confusion with Malcolm’s break from the Nation of Islam and rejection of hate and violence. In the piece, Jackie wondered where exactly Malcolm now stood on Civil Rights and challenged him to more concretely and decisively state what he now believed. Seven months later, Malcolm X was assassinated.

That’s all I could find in the online archives of the FBI’s declassified surveillance project that targeted Black leaders. But what I did find in the files about Jackie Robinson – who today is almost universally revered as a national hero and beloved by many millions of people in America and beyond – was a little chilling, but it also wasn’t exactly surprising.

The presence of Robinson’s name scattered through these archives perhaps reflects how disturbingly far-reaching and all-consuming that the racist, paranoia-driven federal surveillance effort was. As millions of Americans of all races, ethnic backgrounds, genders, ages, orientations and identities were fighting for social justice and egalitarianism, others were seeing “Reds” around every corner and afraid that society was completely collapsing because of it.

I won’t attempt to make parallels between the Hoover-fueled, half-century-long surveillance of Black Americans and the chaos and reactionary splitting at the seams currently engulfing our society and tearing us asunder.

But feel free to do so on your own, of course …

Home Plate Don’t Move will never be placed behind a paywall, but we certainly welcome donations to the effort. To give to Home Plate Don’t Move and its staff — well, me, the staff is me — go here if you’d want. Thanks, and continued thanks for reading!